Departmentalism and the Eviction Moratorium

Bipartisan critics have called the Biden administration’s recent extension of the CDC’s eviction moratorium unconstitutional, but these assessments ignore the history of departmentalism and the important and legitimizing role of the Court’s comprehensive written opinions—something missing in Justice Kavanaugh’s curt concurrence.

The Ethics of “Common-Good Constitutionalism”

Sparking immediate controversy among legal scholars, Harvard law professor Adrian Vermeule’s essay “Beyond Originalism” rejects originalism as merely an instrument to achieve conservative judicial outcomes. To replace it, he advocates for a theory of constitutional interpretation called “common-good constitutionalism”… Even if one agrees with the ends Vermeule seeks, they should be troubled by his means.